MTTM-HEA-3.3
The construction of a composite concrete floor slab is a technique for strengthening timber floors, designed to increase their load-bearing capacity, flexural stiffness and in-plane stiffness. The work involves forming, on the upper surface of the existing floor, a concrete slab – which may be lightweight – generally of modest thickness and reinforced with steel, which is made integral with the timber beams using suitable connection systems. The interaction between the two materials creates a composite section in which the upper concrete slab acts primarily under compression, whilst the timber beams primarily absorb tensile stresses. The connectors also ensure the transfer of shear forces at the interface and limit relative slippage between the timber and the concrete. The connection systems may consist of screws, dowels, metal bars, angled connectors or specifically designed devices. The structural effectiveness of the intervention depends not only on the characteristics of the existing floor slab and beams, but also on the ability of the connections to transfer longitudinal forces and to ensure sufficiently stable behaviour over time. By significantly increasing in-plane stiffness, the floor slab enables the floor structure to contribute more effectively to the distribution of seismic forces amongst the building’s walls. However, this effect must be assessed within the context of the structure’s overall behaviour: in historic masonry buildings, transforming a floor slab that was originally deformable into a very rigid diaphragm can significantly alter the distribution of stresses and does not necessarily result in an improvement in the overall seismic response. For this reason, the intervention requires a particularly careful assessment of the characteristics of the masonry, the floor-to-wall connections and the effects resulting from the increase in mass and stiffness.
The construction of a composite floor slab results in a significant increase in the flexural stiffness and load-bearing capacity of the floor structure, reducing deflections and vibrations whilst improving its service performance. The composite behaviour of timber and concrete allows the mechanical properties of the two materials to be utilised efficiently, with the concrete primarily under compression and the timber primarily under tension. This technique can therefore enable the preservation of historic beams even when, considered in isolation, they are no longer adequate for the required performance. The composite slab also increases the stiffness and strength of the floor structure in its own plane and can act as an effective connecting element between the perimeter walls, facilitating the transfer of horizontal loads to the load-bearing walls. The system can also improve the acoustic and vibration performance and, in certain configurations, the fire resistance of the floor structure. However, the overall performance of timber-concrete composite systems is closely dependent on the characteristics of the connections and the correct sizing of the various components.
The main challenge when carrying out works on historic buildings lies in the permanent increase in mass and the significant increase in the stiffness of the horizontal structural system. The increase in mass results in greater inertial forces during an earthquake, whilst a very stiff diaphragm can transfer higher stresses to the masonry than those present in the original configuration and concentrate the load more heavily on the walls within the storey. Recent studies have shown that the indiscriminate conversion of deformable timber floors into rigid diaphragms using concrete slabs does not necessarily improve the building’s overall seismic response. The technique is rather invasive and offers limited reversibility. The installation of the concrete slab generally requires the removal of floor coverings and sub-floor layers, the insertion of connectors into historic beams, and the use of wet-mix concrete in contact with timber elements – aspects that must be carefully considered where materials or finishes of historical significance are present. It is also necessary to assess the delayed effects resulting from the different rheological and hygrometric behaviour of timber and concrete, the creep of the connections, and changes in mechanical properties over time. The intervention may prove unsuitable where the beams are severely degraded and where the masonry is unable to effectively bear the increased loads transmitted by the floor slab. Furthermore, the intervention may prove inadequate where conservation requirements demand the complete preservation of the existing stratifications and floor coverings.
Before constructing the composite floor slab, the condition of the timber beams must be carefully assessed, paying particular attention to the ends embedded in the masonry, any reduction in cross-section due to biological attack, cracks and permanent deformations. Deteriorated elements must first be stabilised, reinforced or locally replaced using techniques compatible with the original structure. The connection of the floor slab to the perimeter walls is of particular importance. If the timber beams are not adequately anchored to the walls, the construction of the floor slab does not guarantee effective box-girder behaviour of the building. It may therefore be necessary to supplement the works with point or distributed connections between the floor slab and the walls, suitably dimensioned to transfer horizontal forces whilst avoiding localised stress concentrations or mechanisms that could cause the walls to be pushed out. The design must also verify the capacity of the masonry and foundations to withstand the increase in permanent loads and the altered distribution of seismic forces resulting from the increased stiffness of the floor structure. Where the masonry is of poor quality, it may be necessary to carry out preliminary reinforcement of the areas affected by the anchors or supports. In historic buildings, the choice of a composite floor slab should ultimately be weighed up against lighter and reversible solutions, such as double planking, timber panels or steel bracing, whilst comparing their structural effectiveness and impact on conservation.
Applicability and impact
Efficacy
Applicability
Environmental sustainability
Reversibility
Impact
Durability
****
***
*****
**
***
****
Cost and construction logistics
Monetary cost
Construction complexity
Availability (time)
Execution time
Maintenance costs
Regionality
Integrative interventions
Use restriction
***
***
****
***
****
****
***
***
Production process
Degree of innovation
Sustainability
***
****
Structural vulnerability: Horizontal structures (slab).
Ministero per i Beni e le Attività Culturali (2011). Linee guida per la valutazione e riduzione del rischio sismico del patrimonio culturale con riferimento alle norme tecniche per le costruzioni di cui al decreto ministeriale 14 gennaio 2008. Direttiva P.C.M. 9 febbraio 2011.
Ceccotti, A. (2002). Composite concrete–timber structures. Progress in Structural Engineering and Materials, 4(3), 264–275.
Yeoh, D., Fragiacomo, M., De Franceschi, M., & Boon, K.H. (2011). State of the Art on Timber-Concrete Composite Structures: Literature Review. Journal of Structural Engineering, 137(10), 1085–1095.
Mirra, M., & Ravenshorst, G. (2021). Optimizing Seismic Capacity of Existing Masonry Buildings by Retrofitting Timber Floors: Wood-Based Solutions as a Dissipative Alternative to Rigid Concrete Diaphragms. Buildings, 11(12), 604.
Siddika, A., Al Mamun, M.A., Aslani, F., Zhuge, Y., Alyousef, R., & Hajimohammadi, A. (2021). Cross-laminated timber–concrete composite structural floor system: A state-of-the-art review. Engineering Failure Analysis, 130, 105766.