MTTM_MIC2015_Prestazione_energetica

MTTM. UHI-Energy efficiency. MIC 2015 Guidelines.

Assessing the energy performance of a historic building

Introduction

The energy performance of a building represents the annual amount of energy actually consumed, or expected to be required, to meet the various needs associated with standard use of the building. It generally includes winter and summer heating and cooling, domestic hot water production, ventilation, and artificial lighting.

In the case of historic buildings, the energy assessment must be conducted by simultaneously considering performance aspects and the requirements for the preservation of cultural heritage. Energy improvement measures must therefore be compatible with the historical, architectural, and material characteristics of the structure, avoiding permanent alterations or solutions inconsistent with the building’s original construction.

Energy Performance Assessment

Assessing a building’s energy performance requires analyzing various parameters, including:

  • the local climate conditions;
  • the level of thermal insulation of the building envelope;
  • the characteristics of the building services systems;
  • the presence of energy generation systems, if any;
  • the indoor microclimate of the spaces.

Overall energy performance is expressed by the Global Energy Performance Index (EPgl), which represents primary energy consumption per unit of floor area or volume of the building. The index generally includes:

  • winter heating;
  • summer cooling;
  • domestic hot water production;
  • artificial lighting;

The EPgl is derived from the sum of the individual energy contributions related to the various services present in the building and is expressed in kWh/m²-year or kWh/m³-year, in accordance with current European and national regulations.

The resulting value is comparable to other buildings only if the calculation assumptions are consistent. Energy performance, in fact, depends on the methodologies used and can be modified through interventions on the building envelope, on the systems, or on the energy production systems. For the calculation of energy performance indices, reference is made to the UNI Technical Specifications of the 11300 series, as referenced by current Italian regulations

Some issues

In the case of historic buildings, assessing energy performance presents some specific challenges. Traditional construction methods, the historical layering of materials, and the presence of non-standardized technological solutions can make it difficult to accurately determine the building’s thermophysical properties.

The energy assessment must also be conducted at least at two distinct stages: an initial analysis of the building’s current condition and a second assessment aimed at verifying the effects of energy-efficiency improvements. The results obtained may be influenced by the quality of the available data, the calculation methods used, and the level of detail in the preliminary investigations.

An assessment of the effects of energy retrofit projects

The evaluation of energy retrofit projects requires a comparison of pre- and post-renovation conditions in order to verify the actual improvement in the building’s performance.
The results of energy analyses are generally summarized in specific matrices or evaluation schemes prepared by the designer based on the available technical documentation. These documents serve as a tool to assist the relevant conservation authorities in verifying the compatibility of the interventions.

The improvement in the energy performance of a historic building must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, considering not only the achievable energy savings but also the effects of the interventions on the conservation of materials, the thermo-hygrometric behavior of the structures, and overall compatibility with the cultural values of the property.