MTTM_MIC2015_In_01_isolamento_estradosso_non_ventilato

MTTM. Urban Heat Islands and Energy Efficiency in Historic Buildings. MIC 2015 Guidelines

1. Internal and external insulation
In.01. Non-ventilated roof extrados insulation.

MTTM-UHI_MIC-01

Description

Insulating the upper surface of an unventilated roof improves the thermal performance of the building envelope and reduces structural and geometric thermal bridges. The work involves removing and replacing the roof covering by applying a continuous layer of insulation panels protected on the outside by a finishing layer, which may consist of tiles in the case of pitched roofs, or gravel or paving in the case of flat roofs. To ensure the reversibility of the system, it is good practice to use dry joints for the insulation panels; furthermore, it is necessary to verify that the supporting structure is compatible with the additional load resulting from the installation of the panels. Depending on the specific characteristics of the roof, it is possible to opt for the ‘warm roof’ or ‘inverted roof’ system; the use of a vapour barrier can be avoided by using waterproof insulation or by combining hygroscopic and breathable insulation (such as M.4 fibrous materials) with a 1.5–2% slope beneath the insulation layer to allow water to drain away. During installation, it is necessary to check the continuity of the insulation layer to prevent leaks; the most critical points concern thermal bridges due to shape, rainwater collection points and slopes.

Advantages

If the insulation layer is on the outer surface, as with the external insulation system for In.5 vertical enclosures, it ensures the elimination of structural thermal bridges, increasing the surface temperature of the internal walls and reducing the risk of condensation. The use of external insulation allows the thermal inertia of the roof’s load-bearing structure to be utilised to stabilise indoor comfort conditions and optimise the operation of the air-conditioning system.
In the case of pitched roofs or those with a timber frame, the system protects the structure from thermal shocks, helping to extend its lifespan.
In the case of pitched roofs, if the existing tiles are in good condition or have historical and aesthetic value that requires their preservation, they can be reinstalled on the new roof.

Disadvantages and limitations of applicability

Insulation on the upper surface of an unventilated roof alters the building’s external appearance; it may therefore only be installed if it is compatible with the aesthetic and technical characteristics of the roof.
The main disadvantage of insulation on the upper surface of an unventilated roof is the need for a complete roof refurbishment, which may alter the external appearance.
As external insulation allows the roof’s load-bearing structure to act as a thermal mass, this solution is optimised for occupied attic spaces where the heating system operates continuously.

Synergies, interactions and opportunities for complementary interventions

External insulation of an unventilated roof is most effective at reducing thermal bridges when combined with external insulation of the corresponding vertical envelope elements (In.4) and the replacement, retrofitting or refurbishment of windows and doors (In.7·8); to prevent condensation, it is advisable to ensure a certain degree of ventilation within the system.

Assessment against the criteria

Applicability and impacts

Efficacy
Applicability
Environmental sustainability
Reversibility
Impact
Quality of redevelopment
Durability

****
***
***
**
**
**
****

Cost and construction logistics

Monetary cost
Construction complexity
Availability (time)
Execution time
Maintenance costs
Regionality
Integrative interventions
Use restriction

**
**
***
**
****
***
***
***

Production process

Degree of innovation
Sustainability

***
***

Relationship with the indicators of the Risk Analysis Model

Formal vulnerability: Building albedo – Roofs; Mitigations elements in the building – Roofs.
Structural and building services vulnerabilities: Building envelope and its efficiency; Roof constructions materials and their thermal resilience.

References

UNI EN ISO 13788:2003. Hygrometric performance of building components and elements. Italian National Standardisation Body. Milan.
UNI EN ISO 10211:2008. Thermal bridges in building construction. Italian National Standardisation Body. Milan.
Ministerial Decree of 26 January 2010 (Italy). Amendment to the Decree of 11 March 2008 on the energy retrofitting of buildings